New Deal | 8b+ Sport route


Retrospectively recognised as possibly the first 5.14a (8b+) established by an American. Scott Frankin's Scarface at Smith Rock and Planet Claire at the Shawangunks are other contenders for this title.

Chopped by John Bachar as some of the bolts were placed on rappel but subsequently rebolted.

References

[1] https://www.planetmountain.com/en/news/climbing/joshua-tree-scott-cosgrove-visionary-new-deal.html

Contributors
duncancritchley
31 contributions since 10th November 2025.
remus
19 contributions since 12th November 2025.

Pics + Vids

No pics or vids yet.


Ascents

2 recorded ascents.

Climber Style Ascent Date Suggested Grade
Scott Cosgrove Lead | worked 31st Jan 1988 8b
First ascent. 18 sessions.

Graded 13d at the time as Cosgrove had not yet climbed 5.14.

It took me somewhere like 18 days to do it, I think, I had never climb a 14a and the grade did not exist in California, but a 14a Euro-climber tried and failed on the line, shortly after my red-point. He later traveled to Smith Rock and climbed, JB Tribout, To Bolt or Not to Be, very quickly. So, I would say that Alan [Moore]'s rating should stand, as at the time I really didn't know what 13d or 14a was, just that it was damn hard for me and I had to give it a number.

I was in school, guiding full time and training, I had no time or money to go on the road and repeat other 14a, but spent the time climbing routes close to home. I named the climb after FDR plan to put America back to work in the Great Depression, but that metaphor was lost on the many rap bolt haters, who thought I was rubbing it in their face. I felt the small compromise in ethic would lead to higher numbers. (Scott Cosgrove in 2013, after the second ascent)

Alan Moore Lead | worked 2010 8b+