Isn't this just 'The Buttermilker'?

The Buttermilker Sit > Threads > Isn't this just 'The Buttermilker'?
By TdG at 08:20:57 on 10th September 2025.

Can't see any difference between the original and the sit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gyhTjSuZpMw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jrNi7TUVY4M

Post #1 by TdG OP at 08:20:57 on 10th September 2025.

Hmm good question. I just assumed they were separate problems because people have logged them differently on 8a.nu (buttermilker, butter milker sit).

Would be good to get some input from someone who knows the area properly.

Post #2 by remus at 11:16:32 on 12th September 2025.

Reviewing the 27Crags topos by Griffin Whiteside, BM sit starts as low and to the left as it's possible to go, whilst the regular BM seems to be starting off a couple of handholds in the pod slightly to the right – but not clear if that's sitting or not (see Ryan Pasquill vid). Given Tim Clifford's comment, it's not clear if the sit was in fact the original line.

Post #3 by TdG OP at 12:37:47 on 12th September 2025.

CH should sponsor a fact-finding mission to go and investigate 😀

Post #4 by TdG OP at 12:39:30 on 12th September 2025.

People are going to need to up their sponsorship game before there's going to be enough cash in the coffers for that 😅

Post #5 by remus at 12:57:04 on 12th September 2025.